I will say it out loud, I am team Summer all the way.
To be perfectly fair, there should be no ‘right’ and ‘wrong’ in the movie. Not at all. This discussion should not happen at all. End of story. I should stop writing about it.
However, on the internet, I have found a lot of people blaming Summer for giving false hope to Tom, by giving Tom the affection someone who’s in love would have given to his/her spouse. And actually, very few blames Tom, because those who blame Tom, actually do that because they think there’s no problem here at all and they just want to defend Summer (well when I say, ‘they’, it’s actually myself hahaha.)
Okay, here’s my analysis. Let’s start by breaking down the story.
So 500 days of Summer tells a story from Tom’s POV, who met a girl named Summer, and fell head over heels with her, because of her personality and her actions that felt like the actions of someone in love. However, when they first start dating, Summer had stated that she didn’t look for a relationship, she just wanted something casual (read: sex.) However, throughout the story, Tom believed she would change her mind, and Tom tried hard to win her heart. He tried and tried, and he saw (I repeat, from his POV) that maybe he had a chance and Summer would finally changed her mind and would love him from all her heart. In the end, Summer rejected Tom’s advance and after a few things the casual thing finally ended. And after that, Summer got married, leaving Tom heartbroken.
After reading my synopsis. Isn’t this just a tragedy? No one is at fault. Because there is no problem at all. What is the problem? Is it Tom’s heartbreak? How can one’s heartbreak is another person’s responsibility? A heartbreak is always the responsibility of its bearer.
Or you want to argue that Summer lied because she said she didn’t want a relationship and suddenly she got married? Oh how stupid can you be? Sorry, you’re not stupid, you’re just a hypocrite. Have you never, in your life, changed your mind? Changing mind is a 100% legal thing to do.
I have my own personal experience that I want to share, related to this.
Someone, let’s call her J, asked me, where I was going to go that evening.
I said, oh I wanted to go to mall A to shop. She said, OK. However, while I was riding to mall A, I suddenly changed my mind, I went to mall B because I felt like it, maybe I wanted to have dinner at mall B. After arriving at the mall B, J texted and told me that she wanted to ask me to buy a few things from mall A and she would pay me back later. Then I told her that I couldn’t buy that thing because I went to different mall. J was angry with me because she said I told her I wanted to go to mall A.
If you think J’s anger was valid, well you were so wrong. It was not valid. I believe that when we’re angry, we should be angry for the right reason. For example, when an employee made a mistake, we shouldn’t be angry at him/her if it’s an honest mistake. But if it’s negligence or mens rea, then we should be angry at him. I don’t know about other people, but I control my emotion. Yes, emotions may arise without our control, as it often does, they come to the surface of our sea of feelings and materialized as our actions. But if we let every emotion that arise to materialize, then we’d be one hell of unstable immature person. Emotion may arise, but there above the sea, there should be a filter, let’s imagine a layer of oil called reason, that calms the rising emotions so it doesn’t burst without control. Sometimes my filter fails, but I try maintaining it.
Now back to my story (not to Tom and Summer, not yet.) When it first happened to me, I was confused, was I at the wrong side here? I usually went places by myself, freely, why should I suddenly be shackled when someone asked me where I went. When I was by myself, changing my mind shouldn’t be a mistake. Since when changing mind is wrong, WTF? Since then, I always made sure when someone asked me a similar question, I made sure to him/her that I was still unsure and I might change my mind. Heck even if I was sure, I should still be allowed to change my mind.
Now, looking back, now wiser I am, I should just ignore J’s illogical burst of feelings and not take it personally. She was a sucker at controlling her feelings. Her anger feeling arose and she couldn’t control it, she couldn’t understand who’s at fault there, and she let it out and hurt someone else.
It was the same thing as what Summer did. Summer told Tom she didn’t want a relationship. Her aversion to relationship was a promise she made to herself, not to Tom. A promise to our own self is allowed to be cancelled by ourselves. Just like a promise to another person can be cancelled is both parties agree on breaking it. A promise to our own self is simpler because if we ourselves agree on breaking it, then it is the same as both parties breaking it (do you get it?) Back to Summer, she shared her ‘promise to herself’ to Tom so that Tom understood what he was going into. And into he went. That’s why when Summer finally married another person, she was allowed to do it without being called a liar.
And then Tom supporter argued that Summer did to Tom what a person in love would do, even though she knew Tom wanted a real relationship, and her decision to let Tom felt in love with her was cruel, she should have cut Tom earlier.
Okay for this one, you thought about it this way because the movie portrayed this so called tragedy from Tom’s POV. What if you viewed it through Summer’s POV.
“There’s a guy, he’s fun to be with, and he’s also good in bed. I don’t want a real relationship, I just want something casual. I have made it clear to him. But he gave me affection like someone in a relationship, should I return the same kind of affection to him? Okay since we’re close I think I should reciprocate. Wow I think he really wants a real relationship. What he did, he’s doing more than he should. Will I believe in love again, with him? Okay let me try loving him with my heart, who knows with his heart and his effort, it can open again. Oh god damn after a few tries, it still won’t open, it’s closed. This heart just doesn’t feel the spark. I should end it. *after a few months* Welp I met someone and I FINALLY FELT IT IN MY HEART. He proposed to me and I will be married!”
See now? Someone’s feeling is not something to be forced upon. You can’t love someone and expect him/her to love you back and if he/she doesn’t you’ll blame him/her. There’s nothing to blame. It’s heartbreak. If anyone should be blamed, it’s us, it’s our own self, it’s our own heart.
If you said that Summer gave him false hope. It’s so subjective and so your opinion. To you it’s false hope and misleading. But maybe to her, she’s just reciprocating, she could be clueless about it, or she could actually gave hope and tried to let her heart open but it just wouldn’t.
My actual stance is you can’t blame Summer, you can’t blame Tom either (again, no one to blame, it’s a tragedy.) The heart wants what it wants. We can’t control it. What he did, trying to change Summer’s mind was not a mistake. In some scenarios, it could work, and the story would end in Tom and Summer lived happily ever after. But somehow the author decided Summer would not change her mind with Tom, no matter how hard Tom tried.